Replacement Level
Grades 64-609 players
13
Jeremy Crawshaw
Jeremy Crawshaw · P13
60Grade
Jeremy Crawshaw
P13PunterAge 25

The Broncos used a sixth-round draft pick in last year's class to acquire Crawshaw's services. During his first professional season, the Australian native booted the third-most punts and tied for third with 30 punts inside the 20-yard line. However, the Broncos coaching staff is looking for more consistency from the second-year specialist, while "limiting the bad punts."

12
Corliss Waitman
Corliss Waitman · P12
60Grade
Corliss Waitman
P12PunterAge 31

Waitman quietly served as a steady presence for the Pittsburgh Steelers' special teams over the last two seasons. To be fair, the 31-year-old Belgian native took a slight step back in 2025. Waitman's average yards per punt and net punting average decreased. Though his average hang time increased. He also pinned opponents inside the 20-yard line a career-high 34 times. With Cameron Johnston returning to the Steelers, Waitman left and now has the upcoming season to show he can be San Francisco's long-term punter.

11
Ryan Wright
Ryan Wright · P11
61Grade
Ryan Wright
P11PunterAge 26

Wright signed a four-year deal with the Saints this offseason after four seasons with the Minnesota Vikings. The 26-year-old specialist posted career-highs in average yards per punt, net punting average and average hang time during a contract year and benefited. Wright was one of seven punters to average at least 49 yards per punt last season, and he ranked third overall at 44.5 net yards per punt. These increases should dramatically help the Saints' coverage. Though he still needs to prove last year's performance was not a one-year aberration.

10
Jake Bailey
Jake Bailey · P10
62Grade
Jake Bailey
P10PunterAge 29

After a disappointing start to his career as a draft pick by the New England Patriots, Bailey spent the last three seasons with the Miami Dolphins and became a more consistent performer. Furthermore, he showed some improvement through that latest stretch. Specifically, his best two hang-time averages occurred during the past two campaigns. Bailey may not be among the league's best in any specific area, but his recent play led to the Falcons offering him a three-year contract this past offseason.

9
Logan Cooke
Logan Cooke · P9
63Grade
Logan Cooke
P9PunterAge 31

Cooke earned his first Pro Bowl nod and became a second-team All-Pro based on his 2024 performance. While Jacksonville experienced greater team success last season, the Jaguars' eight-year punter took a step back. His punting average and net yards per punt both decreased. Obviously the team's offense took a step forward thanks to Trevor Lawrence blossoming into the quarterback everyone originally envisioned. However, Cooke's touchback rate increased, while his average of punts placed inside the 20-yard line decreased. His average hang time was counted among the league's worst, too.

8
Johnny Hekker
Johnny Hekker · P8
63Grade
Johnny Hekker
P8PunterAge 36

Hekker is no longer the game's best punter and hasn't been for some time. The previous statement does not mean he's no longer a quality option. Although his net punting average was the veteran's lowest since the 2020 campaign. Hekker signed with the Vikings on a one-year deal this offseason. The long-time punter could realistically be pushed by undrafted rookie Brett Thorson, who is the nation's reigning Ray Guy Award winner. Hekker may be the favorite to claim the job, but he needs a little boost after last year.

7
Rigoberto Sanchez
Rigoberto Sanchez · P7
63Grade
Rigoberto Sanchez
P7PunterAge 32

Considering the Colts' scorching hot offensive start to the 2025 campaign, Sanchez became an afterthought. His first punt didn't occur until the second quarter of Week 3 play. In total, Sanchez's 44 punts were the second-fewest by any punter having played the entire season. When called upon, the Colts specialist pinned opponents inside the 20-yard line on half of his attempts. Indianapolis hopes for a bounceback after its horrific end to last season, though Sanchez should be expected to be more involved this fall.

6
Bradley Pinion
Bradley Pinion · P6
64Grade
Bradley Pinion
P6PunterAge 32

After four seasons with the Atlanta Falcons, Pinion joined the Dolphins this offseason. The 32-year-old veteran brings extensive experience for a roster in transition. His greatest asset for Miami this fall is an ability to flip the field. Last season, Pinion led the NFL with 34 punts inside the 20-yard line—which came at a rate of 53 percent of his total attempts—while providing only three touchbacks. Miami's offense is expected to struggle, which makes Pinion's presence vital.

5
Braden Mann
Braden Mann · P5
64Grade
Braden Mann
P5PunterAge 28

Due to the Eagles' offensive inconsistencies, Mann punted more times last season (72) than in either of his previous two campaigns with the franchise. In fact, his usage increased during each of the last two seasons. A year ago, his 49.9 average yards per punt ranked among the league's top five, though his net punting average landed just outside of the Top 10. Mann can boom kicks, but a little more control could place him among the league's top-tier specialists. Even so, the Eagles did reward their punter with a four-year contract extension this past offseason.